Apple FQ1 16 – One way street.

Reply to this post

RFM AvatarSmall






iPhone benefits where Google could not.

  • Apple released excellent results highlighting that contrary to my previous view, iOS has been the main beneficiary of Samsung’s recent woes.
  • FQ1 17A revenues / Adj-EPS were $78.4bn / $3.36 compared to consensus at $77.3bn / $3.22.
  • iPhone was the main driver of the upside with 78.3m units shipped at an ASP of $695 beating expectations of 76.3m units at an ASP of $688.
  • In addition to the share gain, prices went up as the larger screen version of the iPhone saw its biggest contribution to the mix ever.
  • I think that has been primarily driven by Apple taking a good share of users that purchased the Note 7 and were left high and dry by the recall.
  • Users appear to have taken this opportunity to move from Android to iOS, a move which I think is pretty much a one-way street.
  • I find this surprising as the iPhone 6 is now in its third generation meaning that a large screen iOS device has been an option for users for 2.5 years.
  • This means that most high-end Android users have already purchased a new Android device despite a large screen iOS option being available.
  • This is what led me to believe that iOS would not benefit from Samsung’s Note 7 disaster but this logic appears not have been correct.
  • Instead it appears that the negative stigma surrounding the recall has been enough to encourage users to switch away from Android despite the fact that many apps will need to be repurchased.
  • I have estimated that around 2.5m users (see here) were affected by this incident of which I think around 2m have bought an iOS device and 0.5m a Google Pixel device.
  • This explains the strong performance of iPhone, the better mix towards the larger screen device (Note 7 is a large screen) and the geographic performance of Apple during calendar Q4 16.
  • It also explains Apple’s slightly cautious guidance for the coming quarter as this gain is likely to have been a one-off benefit.
  • FQ2 17E revenues / gross margin are expected to be $51.5bn – $53.5bn / 38% – 39% compared to consensus at $53.8bn / 38.7%.
  • This is bad news for Samsung as the crowd that bought the Galaxy Note 7 appear to have switched to iOS from whence they are unlikely to return.
  • Ironically, although Google has failed to win those users over to Pixel, it will still benefit as RFM research indicates that iOS users generate far more advertising revenues for Google than Android users in the same demographic groups.
  • These were good results but they do not herald the return to growth that the shares badly need if they are to see any real upward momentum.
  • I still think that the shares represent great value for income based investors but those looking for capital growth will remain better off with Microsoft, Baidu and Tencent.

3 thoughts on “Apple FQ1 16 – One way street.

  1. ‘I think that has been primarily driven by Apple taking a good share of users that purchased the Note 7 and were left high and dry by the recall.’

    Many of these Note 7 users would have been early adopters and used to having some teething troubles. Samsung gave them strong financial incentives to stay in their ecosystem.

    Tim/Luca said the number of switchers was a record, as were the number of upgraders (but at a similar rate to previous years). I suspect many more of the Android switchers were those who wanted a large screen and needed a new phone, but didn’t have their obvious choice available (no Note 7, Pixel backordered).

    ‘many apps will need to be repurchased’
    As most purchased apps are games, and few of these are played over a long time, the cost of moving for most is unlikely to be that much.

    • I think you are kind of arguing my corner here.

      agree with you on apps.. but still a small consideration when making the switch,

      Whatever incentives Samsung gave, I think a lot of them left anyway…


  2. Pingback: iPhone sales get one-time windfall from Samsung Note 7 woes – Android Fast

Comments are closed.