Nvidia – Knives Out!

Nvidia is not guilty, in my opinion.

  • Nvidia’s long-term prospects depend on the speed with which it can produce new products, and if the company becomes burdened with regulatory oversight, this could damage these prospects materially.
  • This makes the outcome of the Megaspeed (and Inspur) investigation very important, as it will have a bearing on whether Nvidia gets bogged down with compliance or is it able to continue to outpace its competitors and maintain its growth, share and margins.
  • Unfortunately, the knives are now out for Nvidia in the media, meaning that most of the reporting published since the original leak of the memo is compromised with bias, in my opinion, making it unusable for any kind of objective assessment.
  • So far, the only crime that I am aware of that has been committed was the leaking of the classified memo that kick-started the media frenzy, with everything else being in the realm of conjecture.
  • The facts that are undisputed are that a significant number of chips were purchased on the pretext of being deployed in China’s neighbours, with the compute then being rented to Chinese companies, who used it to train and run their AI services for use in China.
  • As of today, there is no prohibition against this practice as long as the data centre is not Chinese-owned, the Chinese tenant does not take ownership of the data centre, the chips are not subsequently imported into China, and the AI trained and run is not for military purposes.
  • Hence, it would be perfectly legal for the Huawei-built data centre in Malaysia owned by Telekom Malaysia to upgrade to Nvidia chips and sell the compute to Alibaba, for example.
  • According to Megaspeed, Inspur, Nvidia’s internal audit and Bloomberg’s 2025 investigation, there is no evidence that any of the 136,000 chips sold to Megaspeed were re-exported to China.
  • There are signs, there are inconsistencies, and there are rumours, but there is no hard evidence in this specific situation.
  • There is evidence that some banned Nvidia equipment has made it into China, but the numbers are small, and it tends to be the smaller DGX solutions rather than the very large NVL72 systems that make it into China, as they are much easier to disassemble and carry in a suitcase.
  • There are also instances where companies have been charged or pleaded guilty to smuggling Nvidia silicon into China (SuperMicro and others), but not in the case of Megaspeed.
  • Megaspeed is much more important than the others because if it is found to have engaged in smuggling, Nvidia and Jensen Huang in particular will appear to have been negligent and unprofessional.
  • Hence, it is the outcome of this investigation that is most likely to impact whether Nvidia’s ability to innovate at speed becomes compromised.
  • Almost all of the evidence presented can be reliably explained by China’s practice of renting data centres overseas and importing the compute for its own use cases.
  • If there were a massive and successful smuggling operation, China would not need to take this elaborate and risky step of renting data centres overseas.
  • The most likely result of this is that general chip restrictions on China are increased further and the rules over who is allowed to rent data centres in foreign countries are also likely to be tightened.
  • There is a negotiation to be had here, as China also has some levers to pull, which include rare earth minerals and its purchase of soybeans, so the eventual outcome, as it relates to export controls, remains uncertain.
  • However, the balance of probability suggests to me that there will not be a regulatory hit or hindrance to Nvidia’s business, meaning that its destiny remains in its own hands and the hands of whoever is recruited to replace Jensen.
  • There is still some risk, as Jensen’s management style was unique and was the foundation of Nvidia’s competitive advantage, which must be preserved at all costs.
  • However, with the shares at $160, this risk looks more than priced in, as Nvidia has at least a year to sort itself out before any damage will be done to financial performance.
  • I have a half position in Nvidia, and am looking to bring it up to a full position sometime in the coming weeks.

RICHARD WINDSOR

Richard is founder, owner of research company, Radio Free Mobile. He has 16 years of experience working in sell side equity research. During his 11 year tenure at Nomura Securities, he focused on the equity coverage of the Global Technology sector.

Leave a Comment