Anthropic IPO – Waiting for Godot

A big day for AI sentiment

  • The manner of Anthropic’s debut in the often brutal public market will be an important barometer of market sentiment, which, following the Nvidia debacle, has taken a nosedive despite no change in any of the underlying fundamentals.
  • Anthropic has raised $81bn through the sale of 980m shares priced at $83, which upsizes the original deal both in terms of the price and the number of shares issued.
  • This is a positive sign as it indicates that there is still plenty of risk appetite for AI-related investments even as Nvidia, rising interest rates and the US election have hammered sentiment on the AI trade more generally.
  • In my opinion, Anthropic is a much riskier proposition than Nvidia, Broadcom, Marvel, Qualcomm, MediaTek, Arm, or any of the other picks-and-shovels plays because all they need is for there to be demand for AI services regardless of where they come from.
  • Every market signal indicates that the demand is there and continues to grow.
  • Anthropic, on the other hand, depends on both this demand and the idea that its models will become the operating system of AI rather than those of OpenAI, open source or anyone else.
  • It also depends on its ability to be able to charge a high enough price for its services so it can cover the cost of its compute which RFM Research continues to estimate is significantly higher than OpenAI.
  • This means that if OpenAI’s products are at least as good as Anthropic’s (and they have materially improved with GPT-6), then OpenAI could undercut Anthropic and trigger a price war.
  • As things stand today, Anthropic’s numbers are fine.
  • Although Anthropic has committed to spend nearly $900bn on compute, this is over a number of years, meaning that in 2027 it will spend something in the order of $100bn and maybe $150bn in 2028.
  • RFM Research estimates that Anthropic will generate around $120bn of revenue in 2027 and $200bn in 2028, both of which are meaningfully below what Anthropic is intending to do.
  • If these targets are met, then Anthropic will not have too much trouble paying its compute bill out of revenue, which is why I am not too worried about the $900bn commitment.
  • Where this falls apart is if Anthropic fails to maintain its edge and gets embroiled in a price war, as then revenues will fall from both market share loss and gross margin declines, having a double whammy on cash flow.
  • This is where the valuation could get into trouble because this would push Anthropic deeper into loss-making territory, meaning that it is forced to come back to the market for more money.
  • This will take a while, as, with the $81bn raised, Anthropic will have something like $200bn of cash, giving it at least 2 years of compute spending before it runs out of money in the worst case.
  • The market is not focused on this risk at all but rather that Anthropic will end up astride the enterprise market across the world, generating 85% gross margins and a lot of cash.
  • Hence, I think that the market will give this a pretty good reception, with the shares ending up somewhere around 10% to 15% up from the IPO price at the end of the trading session.
  • So far, the excellent risk appetite for Anthropic’s proposition has not spread to anyone else, even those who will be big beneficiaries of the $900bn commitment.
  • Hence, it is impossible to tell whether a good day for Anthropic will benefit anyone else, even though almost everyone else offers a much better risk-adjusted return.
  • Between Anthropic and Samsung, Nvidia and Qualcomm, all of whom I own and all of whom are really suffering from the AI doom sentiment, remain far better propositions in my opinion on a risk-adjusted basis.
  • Hence, I remain very comfortable enjoying the Anthropic first-day fireworks from the sidelines.

RICHARD WINDSOR

Richard is founder, owner of research company, Radio Free Mobile. He has 16 years of experience working in sell side equity research. During his 11 year tenure at Nomura Securities, he focused on the equity coverage of the Global Technology sector.

Leave a Comment