USA vs. China – Warning Shot

The bargaining begins.

  • In response to the furore over chip smuggling into China, the Department of Commerce has introduced a new rule that is relaxed enough to be a warning shot rather than a clampdown that immediately puts limits on Chinese companies from renting compute abroad.
  • This makes sense because a hard stop on this practice would hobble China’s AI effort and enrage President Xi, which is probably not what one wants to do right before meeting him on his home turf.
  • The new rule is called Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors, and it creates a compliance requirement for any data centre in the world that sells more than a certain amount of compute to companies headquartered in Macao or any D:5 country.
  • These include China (including Hong Kong), North Korea, Iran, Russia and many of the others that one would expect to be on a list like this.
  • The compute threshold is low enough that, for all intents and purposes, every commercial rental agreement will pass this threshold and require a licence to purchase advanced AI chips.
  • Additionally, any shipments of advanced AI chips to Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand and Brazil for any purpose will now require a lisence unless the buyer’s ultimate parent company is a US-headquartered company and that the exporter meets the reporting requirements.
  • This rule is very different from the kind of licenses that are required by the entity list in that an application for a licence is not made under the presumption of denial.
  • In practice, this means it will be much easier to get a licence under this rule than it is to get a licence to sell goods and services to companies that are on the entity list.
  • However, life will still be more difficult than it was before, meaning lower sales to foreign data centres that serve China, as some will be denied a licence to purchase more chips.
  • This new rule is, in effect, a workaround that will be updated when the Remote Access Security Act makes it into law because, as it stands today, the Commerce Department is unable to regulate compute produced overseas.
  • This is because the current export rules only cover physical items, and so compute generated by a foreign data centre is not an export by definition.
  • The new rule gets around this by saying unless you get a license we won’t let you buy any more chips, which is a much weaker position than trying to regulate the compute itself.
  • When the Remote Access Security Act passes (when not if), this rule will be able to be rewritten to govern the compute itself rather than this less powerful workaround.
  • I see two purposes for this new rule:
    • First, preparing a strike: in that a lot of legwork is needed to put the Commerce Department in a position to put a blanket ban on foreign data centres using US chips to sell compute to China.
    • This also gives time for negotiation, as the Presidents of China and the USA are due to meet twice before the end of 2026 (19th November and 14th December), where the much wider relationship will be hammered out.
    • It appears that the US administration would prefer a continuation of the current strategic grey area rather than a full-blown trade war, and so there may be some movement on this issue over the next month.
    • However, this rule and the coming act get the USA’s tanks lined up to close this loophole, which I think would cause China great consternation given that its domestic compute capacity is not nearly enough to meet its needs.
    • Second, chip smuggling: which is what the 5 new countries added to the list are designed to prevent.
    • There is plenty of evidence that some smuggling of advanced chips into China has occurred, but the amount and materiality of the smuggling is an open question.
    • I think that shipments to these countries will still be permitted, but the level of scrutiny and oversight is going to increase materially.
    • Once again, this could slow down the sales cycle, which would be a problem if there were not such a long queue of customers all trying to get their hands on AI silicon.
  • The net result is that this new rule looks like a placeholder while the requisite legislation passes the Senate and negotiations with China are held.
  • Hence, I think the outcome at the moment is very uncertain and, to a large degree, depends on high-level negotiation.
  • China is not without some levers, as the West will take time to ramp up rare earth mineral production and the USA still has a lot of soybeans to sell.
  • Consequently, I think that the harshness of the implementation of the Remote Access Security Act will depend on what arrangement China and the USA come to behind closed doors.
  • The Nvidia Megaspeed affair has merely served as the catalyst for what was already in the works, although the mood is now for harsher controls compared to a few weeks ago.
  • This is likely to set China back further in the AI race, as its homegrown silicon is still very uncompetitive and I don’t believe it has imported enough illicit chips to make a material difference.
  • Hence, I continue to think that the USA has the advantage in the AI race.

RICHARD WINDSOR

Richard is founder, owner of research company, Radio Free Mobile. He has 16 years of experience working in sell side equity research. During his 11 year tenure at Nomura Securities, he focused on the equity coverage of the Global Technology sector.

Leave a Comment